Andy Kelly Avatar Image

Andy Kelly


Favorite Games:
  • Deus Ex
  • Final Fantasy VII
  • Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater

128 games reviewed
75.0 average score
78 median score
44.5% of games recommended

Andy Kelly's Reviews

Andy Kelly is a journalist based in Bath, England. He writes for PC Gamer and is a contributor to, among others, The Guardian, Vice, GamesRadar+, Edge, and Kotaku. In his spare time he creates the award-winning short film series Other Places (http://www.otherplaces.co.uk/).
30 / 100 - Goat Simulator
Apr 4, 2014

The worst gaming goat since that one in Broken Sword. This is a dumb, limited novelty game that's not worth the asking price.

Read full review

39 / 100 - X Rebirth
Feb 20, 2014

X misses the spot. The occasional bit of spectacle can't save this boring, broken and charmless space simulation.

Read full review

Hotline Miami 2 is a messy, aimless sequel and a step back from the original. Many of its levels feel like crafted set-pieces rather than playgrounds for violent expression, and your scope for creativity is stifled as a result. When you're deep in the moment, chaining kills as that remarkable soundtrack vibrates through your headphones, it feels fantastic. But it struggles to hold onto that feeling as firmly as the first game, diluting the purity of its compelling core loop with an endless parade of under-developed ideas.

Read full review

Apr 25, 2014

Deus Ex: The Fall belongs on your phone, not on your monitor. This is a woeful port with few redeeming features.

Read full review

Jan 31, 2014

Starts out funny, but quickly becomes frustrating. A wonderfully weird and original concept that falls flat like its jelly-limbed hero.

Read full review

50 / 100 - Sonic Forces
Nov 15, 2017

Fans might get a kick out of designing their own character, but weak platforming stops Forces dead in its tracks.

Read full review

52 / 100 - The Complex
Apr 9, 2020

A polished but disappointingly by-the-numbers FMV adventure that won't linger in your mind for long.

Read full review

54 / 100 - Mafia 3
Oct 11, 2016

Starts promisingly, but soon slips into a tiresome, repetitive grind, never doing its unique period setting justice.

Read full review

55 / 100 - The Crew 2
Jun 29, 2018

An impressively huge, occasionally beautiful map doesn't make up for mediocre driving and a lack of multiplayer options.

Read full review

58 / 100 - Resident Evil 3
Mar 30, 2020

Both the Nemesis and Raccoon City are massively underused in this disappointing step back for the series.

Read full review

58 / 100 - Extinction
Apr 10, 2018

Impressive ogre battles and challenging, hectic missions, but I just wish there was a bit more to Extinction.

Read full review

Feb 26, 2018

Has flickers of brilliance, but the painfully slow and gruelling survival simulation routinely snuffs them out.

Read full review

An increased focus on action and unsatisfying cases overshadow the decent bits in this detective adventure.

Read full review

Aug 18, 2021

Twelve Minutes is a good adventure game, but its puzzle design makes it feel— mature, cinematic presentation aside—like something of a relic. If it was released in 1995, you'd be ringing up the LucasArts hint line for help and getting scolded by your parents for running up a massive phone bill. But it has its charms, and the way the story is gradually peeled back, growing more disturbing with each loop, is effectively done. There's a huge amount of emotion, drama, and conflict squeezed into this tiny, dingy three-room apartment. But also a lot of frustration as you struggle to determine precisely the correct sequence of events to let you move the story forward and finally get some closure.

Read full review

Jul 4, 2018

A well-made remaster with beautiful modern visuals and outdated platforming rooted firmly in the past.

Read full review

Mar 20, 2017

Boasts some beautiful, convincing countryside to hunt in, but the glacial pace will challenge the limits of most people’s patience.

Read full review

Jul 28, 2015

An open-world samurai adventure with an interesting structure and a lot of personality that is, unfortunately, not very good.

Read full review

60 / 100 - Unrest
Aug 1, 2014

A compelling story with many outcomes, but the game itself is a little too rough around the edges.

Read full review

63 / 100 - Days Gone
May 17, 2021

Riding and maintaining your bike is great-the boring world, dull missions, and overly serious tone, not so much.

Read full review

Jan 18, 2016

A beautiful remaster of a game that tries to recreate the magic of the original Resident Evil, but repeatedly fails to do so.

Read full review